The Saga of a case for my '65 M20

jgmaute

Member
Joined
Mar 31, 2008
Messages
733
Reaction score
37
Location
Foothills of the Rockies
I was going to wait until I have the actual case in my possession and could post pictures but I might as well start the story now.

The Challenge and the Saga Begins
As anyone who has an old F20 or M20 knows, finding a hardshell case for one is next to impossible. (Even the chipboard cases that they originally came in aren't that great a fit.) I've been using a Taylor gig bag for mine but went in search of a hardshell case. Parlor and 00 cases are too small. Triple 0 or 0M cases are too big. There is a 3/4 case that almost fits, but it's 1/4" too small in the top bout and 1" too short in total length (interior case length is 38", guitar is 39"). I spent hours on case sites, talked to many stores (Elderly really gave it a try, even said they wanted to research it more then called me back unable to find anything) but couldn't find anything.
The "Impossible Find" Path
I remembered reading that Jeff had gotten a GADF20/M20 case and it was a perfect fit. I also remembered he said they were next to impossible to find. That sent me down the impossible find path. Guild dealers told me they couldn't order the case without a guitar. Somewhere along the line I found a GADF20 on CraigsList in the Miami area. The poster wanted $325 or best offer for a GADF20 including case. I jumped on that one right away figuring I could sell the guitar in a gig bag and keep the case. Well, it was already gone (and for less than $325). I called my local luthier, Randy Wood, to see if he had an in with case makers since he custom builds guitars. Randy suggested I call Guild and see who makes the case then call the case builder and see if I could get one from them.
The Call to Guild
I called Guild Customer Service. Before asking who made the cases, I explained that I have a '65 Guild M20, that I've been playing Guilds since 1968 etc. and am looking for a hardshell case for the M20. I also told the guy that the current GAD F/M20 case fits my guitar but local dealers tell me they are unable to order one. He said that didn't seem right and would I hold while he checked something. Of course I held. He came back and said, "We've got them, the part # is XXXXXXXXXX and they're in stock. I don't know why you're hearing they can't be ordered." I asked if I could just order one from them and he said No, it had to be ordered from a dealer or parts distributor. He then suggested Music Parts Guru and gave me the #. I thanked him profusely, hung up and made the next call.
The Call to Music Parts Guru
I called Music Parts Guru which is near O'Hare airport in IL and told my story to Corey. Corey looked up the part number, found it, then asked me to hold while he called Guild to make sure they were in stock. A few minutes later he came back on line to tell me that there is a "warranty hold" on 0065671000 which means that part can only be ordered to replace an original that has a warranty problem. He was unable to order the part. "But wait!!" I said, I just talked with them and was told you could get one for me. Then he asked the question..."Do you have the name of the person you talked to?"...you know the answer...I did not have that name. But I said I'd call Customer Service and hopefully get the same guy.
The Second Call to Guild
I called Guild Customer Service back right away. When a guy answered I told him my name and asked if he was the person I'd just talked to about getting a case for a Guild GADF/M20. He said he wasn't but he was sure he could help me. So...first I asked him for his name then you know the drill. I repeated my story of why I wanted a case, that I talked with someone a little while ago who'd given me the part #, said they were in stock, and suggested I call Parts Guru. Then I related my call to Corey and what he'd found out about the warranty hold. My soon to be new best friend said he'd check on it and would I hold. He came back to tell me Corey was correct, there was a warranty hold and the cases could actually only be ordered by repair centers who were doing warranty work. I tried not to whine but did share my disappointment. Then this wonderful Guild Customer Service guy who knows what good customer service is said he'd release one to Parts Guru. He asked me to tell Corey to call him direct and he'd take care of it. Once again the call ended with me profusely thanking the Guild Customer Service guy (who shall remain nameless for his own protection).
Parts Guru, Call Two
Armed with this info I called Corey back. I gave him the name of the person at Guild (he said that's who he usually deals with there, good sign) and told him he could call and order one. He said he'd do that then call me back once he had details, price, etc.
The Order is Placed!
I got a call back from Corey and he said all was set; he'd ordered a case and they would receive it in about a week then send it to me. (I'd asked about "drop shipping" from Guild...no go on that.) The price was a little over $225...damn that's expensive...but I really wanted the case and after all that went ahead and ordered it. I told Corey there were other folks on LTG who probably would be interested in a case and did he think someone else could try this by starting with Guild. He said he didn't know if it would work twice but he did know they only had 2 or 3 cases in stock and one was coming to me.

are you still reading? I'll take a break then come back later with the next installment...jm

3/23/10...incorrect part # Xed out to prevent problems for others...
 

killdeer43

Reverential Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2008
Messages
21,848
Reaction score
113
Location
Northwest Washington on the Salish Sea
jgmaute said:
are you still reading? I'll take a break then come back later with the next installment...jm
Darn, just as the plot thickened! :wink:
But seriously, have you tried the M20 in the case for your GAD30 (if you have one)?
Just curious to know if it would fit and how good a fit it might be.

Curiosity rules,
Joe
 

capnjuan

Gone But Not Forgotten
Gone But Not Forgotten
Joined
Nov 29, 2006
Messages
12,952
Reaction score
4
Location
FL
Hi Joan and yes ... still reading! At the risk of a veer, FMIC Customer Relations people furnished FMIC's entire e-library of Guild amplifier schematics to LTG foregoing their fee; it was a very fine gesture. :D
 

john_kidder

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 21, 2005
Messages
3,103
Reaction score
6
Location
Ashcroft, BC, Canada
killdeer43 said:
have you tried the M20 in the case for your GAD30 (if you have one)?
Just curious to know if it would fit and how good a fit it might be
Had a GAD30 for a few weeks (nice little guitar, too).

The case is approximately F30 size - too large for an M/F20.
 

drive-south

Member
Joined
Oct 18, 2006
Messages
113
Reaction score
0
Location
Worcester, MA
Are you getting one of those green tweed cases that the GAD series are shipped in? If so there is no way I would pay $225 for one of these cases. I used to own a GAD JF30 and although the case looks nice from 10' away, they are among the most flimsy cases I've ever seen. The hadware is check, and tweed fabric is not glued onto the case securely and the case itself is light and flimsy.

There has to be other options out there. Have you tried SKB? They source cases for Gibson and many others.

drive-south
 

kostask

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 28, 2006
Messages
1,019
Reaction score
486
Hi,

I am in agreement with the flimsy nature of the GAD cases. I have seen such a case for the GAD 30R, and wouldn't be inclined to buy one, at any price.

For a suitable case, you may want to see how well a Taylor hardshell case fits. Taylor's cases seem to be build extremely well; my GAD 30R arrived in one, and it fits really well, and it a really solid case. Taylor does make cases for smaller guitars (I don't remember the Taylor numbering scheme, but it probably is a X10 or X12 that would be the size that would fit an F20).

TKL also has a number of case sizes, in various lines. You can check their website, and figure out what fits and which series you like, and then check to see if you have any dealers locally that carry TKL.

The F20, being the size that it is, may also fit into some classical guitar cases. Things like actual side curvatures and neck lengths may be a problem, but as the cases vary somewhat in almost all dimensions, there are some classical guitar cases that may fit.

Kostas
 

Default

Super Moderator
Platinum Supporting
Joined
Jul 30, 2007
Messages
13,652
Reaction score
3,080
Location
Philly, or thereabouts
Guild Total
11
cjd-player said:
I admire your determination and persistence, Joan.

You go girl !!!


Or as Scratch would say; You da man! :oops:

Ditto from me! As someone who was looking for a case for my Starfire, off the shelf cases are not suitable for all models that Guild produced. Sometimes, you can go cheap (Coffin Cases) but other times you have to pony up. :(
Waiting for installment two.
 

Jeff

Enlightened Member
Joined
Mar 23, 2006
Messages
5,990
Reaction score
4
Location
seattle
kostask said:
Hi,


. Taylor does make cases for smaller guitars (I don't remember the Taylor numbering scheme, but it probably is a X10 or X12 that would be the size that would fit an F20).

TKL also has a number of case sizes, in various lines. You can check their website, and figure out what fits and which series you like, and then check to see if you have any dealers locally that carry TKL.

The F20, being the size that it is, may also fit into some classical guitar cases. Things like actual side curvatures and neck lengths may be a problem, but as the cases vary somewhat in almost all dimensions, there are some classical guitar cases that may fit.

Kostas


F20s are a somewhat unique size & shape. I've tried dozens of cases, Classical cases are better than no case but not close to an aceptable fit. Closest thing I could find was a case designed for a Martin 00, & even that required a couple dish towells as padding to keep the guitar from moving loosely inside the case.

I've not seen all Taylor's models but I've never seen a Taylor guitar the same shape & size as an F20. Taylor might be a good place to investigate.

Calton cases claim the will will make cases to any specifications. I saw a Calton cases in Arlington last year, top of the line no nonsense case it was. Just speculation but I'd guess $250 would be enough for a deposit on one of these, custom built. Elderly wants $800 for their in stock models.

caltoncolors.jpg


http://caltoncases.com/
 

fungusyoung

Senior Member
Joined
May 20, 2006
Messages
1,274
Reaction score
1
Location
DE
Guild Total
2
Now, that's persistence! I hope it all works out, but you gave it everything you could. Well done!

We all need to protect our babies with cases... I remember going down a similar path with my F112. I eventually found a perfectly fitting Guild case for it, though it was discovered entirely by accident as it was shipped with another Guild (dread!) I'd bought. It actually fit both guitars pretty well, but dread cases are a dime a dozen.
 

john_kidder

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 21, 2005
Messages
3,103
Reaction score
6
Location
Ashcroft, BC, Canada
There is an outfit here in Vancouver that will (at, least, a couple of years ago they would) build 5-ply archtop cases to spec for around $125. If folk are interested, I can inquire if they're still in the trade?
 

jgmaute

Member
Joined
Mar 31, 2008
Messages
733
Reaction score
37
Location
Foothills of the Rockies
The Saga continues...

Before I continue I'll respond to some of the posts. Yes I have a case for my GAD 30R, it didn't come with one and it was a challenge finding one to fit but I got a great one and it only cost around $125. It's too big for the M20. My Martin is a 00, its case is too small in the length and upper bout. All the classical cases I found were too short (that large Guild headstock...) and many had an upper bout that was 3" or more large than the upper bout. I checked out Carlton but not only was it too expensive, it takes at least 6 weeks and this case was needed ASAP. In terms of the quality vs the cost I will say that not matter what the quality it will be better than the gig bag I'm currently using...and I am posting the list price because that is what Guild told Guru they had to charge me. Another part I factored in is that I really got a deal on the guitar so...that's the decision I made.

When we last left the Saga I had ordered the case and it was supposed to be in Chicago in a week or less then they'd ship it right to me. After a week and a half I called Corey. Corey was working with another customer but the guy I talked to knew all about the case. Turns out even after it was ordered they had some extra hoops to jump through so it was delayed. The case arrived in Chicago on Tuesday and was shipped out that day. It's due here the 22. It got as far as Raleigh. NC by 5:36 AM this morning. It hasn't been scanned at departure yet so maybe it's spending the weekend in Raleigh. It will be interesting to see if it makes it here on Monday.

Of course after all this Capnjuan found a GAD case on ebay GAD Case for $49 plus shipping. It's just arrived and based on the measurements I'm not sure if it's the same size as the case I'm getting or not. When I talked with Guild we went over the measurements at length plus Jeff's fits just fine. stay tuned...next installment sometime Monday.

If the company in Vancouver will still make a custom case for $125 that seems like a great deal based my experience so far. joan
 

capnjuan

Gone But Not Forgotten
Gone But Not Forgotten
Joined
Nov 29, 2006
Messages
12,952
Reaction score
4
Location
FL
Re: The Saga continues...

jgmaute said:
... Of course after all this Capnjuan found a GAD case on ebay GAD Case for $49 plus shipping. It's just arrived and based on the measurements I'm not sure if it's the same size as the case I'm getting or not. When I talked with Guild we went over the measurements at length plus Jeff's fits just fine. ..
Hi Joan; I've compared case measurements with Jeff off-board and his case differs a little from what I have; his is a 1/2" longer, 2" longer in the body cavity, and 1" shallower although the bout measurements are about the same. My seller offered me the chance to back out because of his uncertainty over which Guild/GAD models it fit ... turns out being sure of that is harder than it looks at first.

I was also thinking about your 'Warranty Hold' comments ... I mean I wonder if it was ok for him to sell it at all ... or ... worse, he sold a case that had been ordered for someone else ... someone like you who'd spent hours tracking on of these down only to lose out because they sold it in error :evil: .

Anyway, looking forward to more of your saga; you are relentless! CJ
 

jgmaute

Member
Joined
Mar 31, 2008
Messages
733
Reaction score
37
Location
Foothills of the Rockies
Re: The Saga continues...

capnjuan said:
[
I was also thinking about your 'Warranty Hold' comments ... I mean I wonder if it was ok for him to sell it at all ... or ... worse, he sold a case that had been ordered for someone else ... someone like you who'd spent hours tracking on of these down only to lose out because they sold it in error :evil: .
Anyway, looking forward to more of your saga; you are relentless! CJ

Based on the way the ebay ad was written and the other guitar cases the same seller had listed my guess was that somehow cases got separated from the guitars...who knows, maybe someone wanted a deal on the guitar and paid less and let them keep the case. And yes, I can be relentless...chalk it up to being a retired teacher with research skills and time, when I was working I barely had time to play my guitar let alone go on the hunt for a case! joan
 

BluesDan

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 3, 2007
Messages
1,407
Reaction score
0
Location
New York
This topic comes up quite often and there are always those who suggest checking various manufacturers for a case that may be a precise fit for the M20 / F20. I know that many, including myself , have researched this and always come up empty handed, with the exception being the manufacturers that make custom fit orders. I have settled on an "almost fit" OO Martin case which, like Jeff says, requires a sock stuffed by the lower bout. I have been keeping my eyes open for one of those GAD M20 cases to come up on the bay at a reasonable price. But as for fnding a Martin, Taylor, TKL or other that fits......I can state with reasonable certainty that "it aint gonna happen".

This is what I came up with as criteria for a "precise' fit for my '59 M20:
Upper bout 10 3/8"
Lower bout 13 3/4"
Overall length 39"
Body length 18"

Considering the alternatives, I think Joan did very well.
 

capnjuan

Gone But Not Forgotten
Gone But Not Forgotten
Joined
Nov 29, 2006
Messages
12,952
Reaction score
4
Location
FL
Re: The Saga continues...

Joan said:
... And yes, I can be relentless...chalk it up to being a retired teacher ...
Hi Joan; I can't help but be reminded of Mrs. V_____r who was my 7th grade English teacher. She didn't teach us to diagram sentences, she surgically implanted the skill ... I can still see the chalkboards with the sentences on them on the head and sidewalls of the classroom ... K-12, she was the best. I don't know how my seller came to cut this one loose but I did get the sense that he hadn't intended to ... if for no other reason than to preserve the chance to hose someone down the road. :(

Dan said:
This is what I came up with as criteria for a "precise' fit for my '59 M20: .... Considering the alternatives ...
Hi Dan; my case is 1" or so wider in the upper bout and 3/4" wider in the lower ... eh ... a little sloppy side-to-side. If you could live with that, the most critical dimensions would be the heel-to-waist and waist-to-shoulder. As a practical matter, the G-men don't offer an alternative. Not too hard to imagine them buying the GAD (and standard) cases in large lots such that once gone, the cases can't be bought from the source at the bulk rate and instead, become expensive one-offs ... so it would make sense to buy some 'warranty spares' explaining why they are so retentive ... who knows.
 

coastie99

Enlightened Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2006
Messages
8,662
Reaction score
27
Location
Greymouth, West Coast, Newsyland
john_kidder said:
There is an outfit here in Vancouver that will (at, least, a couple of years ago they would) build 5-ply archtop cases to spec for around $125. If folk are interested, I can inquire if they're still in the trade?

Please count me in John ........ I've been thinking that somewhere out there, there has to be a bespoke case-maker who'd be happy to make a run of F/M20 cases.

Perhaps canvass the membership in a specific post ?
 

john_kidder

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 21, 2005
Messages
3,103
Reaction score
6
Location
Ashcroft, BC, Canada
coastie99 said:
john_kidder said:
There is an outfit here in Vancouver that will (at, least, a couple of years ago they would) build 5-ply archtop cases to spec for around $125. If folk are interested, I can inquire if they're still in the trade?

Please count me in John ........ I've been thinking that somewhere out there, there has to be a bespoke case-maker who'd be happy to make a run of F/M20 cases.

Perhaps canvass the membership in a specific post ?
I'll try to find the company again next week, and get back to everyone.
 

twocorgis

Venerated Member
Gold Supporting
Joined
Jan 8, 2010
Messages
14,124
Reaction score
6,752
Location
Lawn Guyland
Guild Total
18
john_kidder said:
coastie99 said:
[quote="john_kidder":2v2e19t9]There is an outfit here in Vancouver that will (at, least, a couple of years ago they would) build 5-ply archtop cases to spec for around $125. If folk are interested, I can inquire if they're still in the trade?

Please count me in John ........ I've been thinking that somewhere out there, there has to be a bespoke case-maker who'd be happy to make a run of F/M20 cases.

Perhaps canvass the membership in a specific post ?
I'll try to find the company again next week, and get back to everyone.[/quote:2v2e19t9]

I'll take one too John, for my new to me F20.

Count me in.
 

jgmaute

Member
Joined
Mar 31, 2008
Messages
733
Reaction score
37
Location
Foothills of the Rockies
The Saga Continues

So...we went out of town yesterday and got back around 5 this afternoon, no case. The door bell just rang and when I got the the door the UPS guy had already gotten back in his truck having left the box on the front porch. I immediately took it to the guest room to open the box on the bed so I could slide it out of the box easily.

The Good
When I took the case out turns out it's not the tweed case but a pretty nice black case...but gee...it seems a bit big...
The Bad
I opened the case and got my M20 from it's Gig Bag to put it inside the case...
and The Ugly
damn it...it's too big! I am NOT happy. Doing further research I find that
•the packing slip has the part # I was given by Guild and therefore ordered, 0065671-000...seeing the dash between the #s I get a sinking feeling...000...CRAP! Was I given the wrong part #?
•doing some research I find the label on the box says part # 0065671000 VALENCIA TKL...
•the tag on the actual case does NOT have that part # but does have the Valencia #...
The REALLY Ugly
Tomorrow morning I'll start with a call to Parts Guru...

additional happenings in the two hours since I got home.
*I got an email from Oasis that they haven't received my master CD for my new album. Well, I've got the tracking that shows they signed for it March 12...I was expecting it tomorrow, kiss that off...they're east coast time zone so that is the first call I'll make.
* I got an email from the guy in FL who is selling a GADF20 with case that he had trouble with the last seller and it's available

but...life is good, we heard an amazing concert Sunday night...and all and all it's just "stuff"...

bet you can't wait for tomorrow's post, eh? joan
DSC02122.jpg
DSC02121.jpg
DSC02119.jpg
DSC02120.jpg
 
Top