Why Do We Play, Collect Guitars and Compose

Rich Cohen

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 22, 2015
Messages
3,177
Reaction score
2,307
Location
Charlottesville, VA
I'm sure there are multiple answers to the questions of this thread. It will be interesting to hear all of you.
For me, I play the guitar essentially for myself, for my own sanity. I compose to amuse myself and others. I collect guitars, in modest numbers, due to economic constraints and maintaining marital bliss (unattainable). That's it in a nutshell. After reading your reactions, I'll weigh in again I suppose.
 

walrus

Reverential Member
Gold Supporting
Joined
Dec 23, 2006
Messages
24,049
Reaction score
8,128
Location
Massachusetts
Like you, at this point in my life I am playing essentially for myself. I find it very relaxing and enjoyable, a great stress reliever. I also enjoy learning new songs, and as I read more research on aging, I know it is keeping my brain a bit sharper.

I don't collect guitars, however. Having learned hundreds of songs over the years, one might argue I collect songs instead.

walrus
 

Rich Cohen

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 22, 2015
Messages
3,177
Reaction score
2,307
Location
Charlottesville, VA
Like you, at this point in my life I am playing essentially for myself. I find it very relaxing and enjoyable, a great stress reliever. I also enjoy learning new songs, and as I read more research on aging, I know it is keeping my brain a bit sharper.

I don't collect guitars, however. Having learned hundreds of songs over the years, one might argue I collect songs instead.

walrus
I'm headed in that direction too.
 

Brad Little

Senior Member
Gold Supporting
Joined
Dec 19, 2008
Messages
4,634
Reaction score
2,032
Location
Connecticut
I play guitar because I've been doing it for 60 years or more. When I was playing regularly, I wrote songs to play out, now I write very little. I collect guitars because I like them and can afford some I couldn't when I was gigging more regularly. They probably would have gotten a lot more playing back then, as I don't even play every day any more, and I used to play several hours most days.
 

richardp69

Enlightened Member
Gold Supporting
Joined
Aug 11, 2009
Messages
6,036
Reaction score
6,069
Location
Barton City, Michigan
Everybody needs and outlet, something to look forward to, something to excite them and something to challenge them and keep them busy.

Since I've given up most all of my bad vices I do this instead. I'm not good enough to justify what I've bought/collected but that's o.k. I'm good enough for me and that's all I care about.

I'm a pretty good buyer and don't typically overpay for what I buy. So, I also look at my guitars as another extension to my 401k investments. I/my heirs may not get all the money back but I think we can reasonably expect to get most of it. I'm also happy to pass along my gear to friends and acquaintances at what I paid for it or less. I get pleasure out of that as well.

Lastly, I worked pretty hard for 31 years before I retired. Some folks buy vacation homes/property or classic cars or go on exotic vacations. I don't do any of that. I just buy/sell/trade guitars and feel I've earned the right to do so.
 

spoox

Member
Joined
Dec 3, 2014
Messages
735
Reaction score
1,504
I wrote my first song at 3 1/2...COWBOYS DON'T KISS MOO COWS. I wanted to play guitar because of Elvis and Ricky Nelson--so my dad got me a Hawaiian guitar when I was nine!? I took Spanish guitar lessons when I was thirteen for awhile, then my dad bought me a Kay thin twin, which a year later somehow became my Guild Polara while I was at school one day. In my first two bands we did covers only, but in '71 we morphed into a group that did pretty much original songs only. Still only my S100 but also a double neck Fender steel and a 7 string Dobro. After hanging out with John Dopyera I got my
Supro and started collecting Dobros and Nationals. Our band got back together in 2007, but I didn't get my second Guild until 2014. All these years I'd been writing songs and poetry ( I believe one of the reasons Vicki first liked me) but when my wife was diagnosed with dementia in 2012 the songwriting became even more important as a way of dealing with things. Doctors asked if I would like drugs or a therapist to help me and I would reply "No thanks--then I would be sad and on drugs!--and songwriting and playing guitar is my therapy".
I consider my self more a songwriter than musician--and I do have the collector gene. However I find with each new (to me) instrument I'm able to come up with new song ideas...my only problem I currently face is how to take my '65 F212 with me to an afterlife...oh, and one of my Dobro ukes...and one of my squarenecks...etc. etc.
No sitting on a cloud playing a harp for me...
 

Bernie

Member
Joined
Apr 10, 2018
Messages
773
Reaction score
303
Location
Occitania
I play because I love the songs that I play, because I keep willing to improve my playing them, and because too I want or need to express myself or/and what they say...

I don't collect guitars, but can't find much will to sell any, as they all have something interesting or valuable in their own way; and then end up owning quite a few - many still quite cheap.

I compose or write because that's the natural way of playing music, or to express myself again, or because I'm pretentious enough to think I might have something valuable or important to deliver to humanity... ☺I play music too, whatsoever mine or other"s, coz I have reasons to have to make some money this way too...
 
Last edited:

mellowgerman

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2008
Messages
4,139
Reaction score
1,568
Location
Orlando, FL
My parents always had music playing at home in one form or another, so my love for music probably started when I was still in the womb. Though they never played instruments or sang, they owned a restaurant and for several years a lot of the kitchen guys happened to be musicians (good workers referring their friends, seemed to keep the high school rock-and-rollers rotating through). Being in the pre-internet days, they always had guitar magazines and catalogs in the break room. Already being a music fan, I was naturally intrigued, flipping through pages and pages of gear, and started dreaming of learning myself. I first took on bass in 6th grade and guitar a couple of years later. Of course, very few things make a freshman cooler than walking around school with a bass gig bag on his back, so I was proud of my music involvement and I really started to embrace it as a part of my identity.
I began writing my own music around junior year of high school and found it to be a great outlet for my emotions and a way to process the things going on in my life. I've been gigging (playing mostly original material) and participating in jam sessions pretty much ever since. I only did it professionally 2014-2015, successfully enough to get by, but quickly found that turning music into my job made me not want to touch instruments outside of rehearsal or concerts. I also don't think I'm really cut out for the lonely life on the road... always having been very close with my family, I may be more of a settler type than a nomad type. So I went back to just working a full-time job and doing music for enjoyment. Much happier this way. Thus far I've made some amazing friends via music, learned a lot about myself (and sound and electronics and wood, etc.), and have had some pretty interesting music-related experiences and adventures. Even happened to meet my amazing wife while on tour!
Why do I collect instruments? Between basses, classical guitars, steel-string acoustics, and electric guitars, I really just consider what I have to be a modest collection, though for at least a decade I got a ton of enjoyment out of cycling through different ones by taking advantage of the internet's buy/sell/trade resources; kind of a quest for THE tone/feel that I knew was out there but didn't know exactly where to get it. That's been dwindling and I've found that my current little collection feels pretty concrete, almost like I've found the ones that are really "right" for me. The timing might be just right too, as in the last few years I've married, become a homeowner, and expect that the next few years will likely bring about some mini-mellowgermans. Of course I'm sure I'll always keep on casually browsing the used market and dabbling with new-to-me guitars/basses now and then. Maybe here and there one will take a spot in the long-term stable, but for the most part, I'm pretty content with what I have.
 
Last edited:

Stuball48

Senior Member
Gold Supporting
Joined
Oct 22, 2017
Messages
4,794
Reaction score
2,588
Location
Dickson, TN
Everybody needs and outlet, something to look forward to, something to excite them and something to challenge them and keep them busy.

Since I've given up most all of my bad vices I do this instead. I'm not good enough to justify what I've bought/collected but that's o.k. I'm good enough for me and that's all I care about.

I'm a pretty good buyer and don't typically overpay for what I buy. So, I also look at my guitars as another extension to my 401k investments. I/my heirs may not get all the money back but I think we can reasonably expect to get most of it. I'm also happy to pass along my gear to friends and acquaintances at what I paid for it or less. I get pleasure out of that as well.

Lastly, I worked pretty hard for 31 years before I retired. Some folks buy vacation homes/property or classic cars or go on exotic vacations. I don't do any of that. I just buy/sell/trade guitars and feel I've earned the right to do so.
Well said Richard and agree 100% with your reply.
Many of us collect or have collected other items - the hunt and find are what keep me excited.
 

Guildedagain

Enlightened Member
Joined
Jun 8, 2016
Messages
9,106
Reaction score
7,266
Location
The Evergreen State
I play as a form of mental exercise, mind over matter. I'd like to play anywhere on the neck, in any key, and always hit the note I'm looking for next without error. I'm progressing.

I don't collect guitars, I just always seem to be wanting another one.

So I have too many and some are near impossible to get rid of, they're just too good.
 

davismanLV

Venerated Member
Joined
Mar 24, 2011
Messages
19,391
Reaction score
12,235
Location
U.S.A. : Nevada : Las Vegas
Guild Total
2
Everybody needs and outlet, something to look forward to, something to excite them and something to challenge them and keep them busy.

Since I've given up most all of my bad vices I do this instead. I'm not good enough to justify what I've bought/collected but that's o.k. I'm good enough for me and that's all I care about.

I'm a pretty good buyer and don't typically overpay for what I buy. So, I also look at my guitars as another extension to my 401k investments. I/my heirs may not get all the money back but I think we can reasonably expect to get most of it. I'm also happy to pass along my gear to friends and acquaintances at what I paid for it or less. I get pleasure out of that as well.

Lastly, I worked pretty hard for 31 years before I retired. Some folks buy vacation homes/property or classic cars or go on exotic vacations. I don't do any of that. I just buy/sell/trade guitars and feel I've earned the right to do so.
What Richard said. I don't play because I'm good at it but because it makes me happy. I enjoy it! Playing for others not so much. As soon as it's not for me, and becomes "entertainment" for others I lose interest really quickly. I don't collect guitars. Never even thought I'd have five, but I enjoy them all and enjoy my time with them. Lately, I haven't been playing so much, but it's a mood thing. It'll come back around again. All five in different tunings so very rarely are there huge retunings which makes life easier. I'm all about life being easier....
 

Stuball48

Senior Member
Gold Supporting
Joined
Oct 22, 2017
Messages
4,794
Reaction score
2,588
Location
Dickson, TN
What Richard said. I don't play because I'm good at it but because it makes me happy. I enjoy it! Playing for others not so much. As soon as it's not for me, and becomes "entertainment" for others I lose interest really quickly. I don't collect guitars. Never even thought I'd have five, but I enjoy them all and enjoy my time with them. Lately, I haven't been playing so much, but it's a mood thing. It'll come back around again. All five in different tunings so very rarely are there huge retunings which makes life easier. I'm all about life being easier....
Your last six words work for me.
 

crank

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 26, 2009
Messages
1,248
Reaction score
888
I play therefore I am.

Could no more stop playing than I could fly.

I only have 7 guitars and haven't bought or sold one in a few years. I have 2 I don't really use really anymore, but have had them for soo many years they has sentimental value. still thinking about selling both to fund getting a good one of those hybrid guitars just to make it easier to play acoustic as my hands get weaker. Depressing, I know. So I don't really collect - I just grow attached.

I have too many other hobbies I am passionate about to get involved in collecting; though I love seeng everyone els's collections and acquisitions.

I figure that all my guitars should sound great and it is up to me to learn how to make them do so. Am I up to the task? Let's just say it keeps me busy.

I only write occasionally, when something inspires me. I like to grab a guitar and take it out into nature and then compose something that seems to fit the scenery. I used to play in original bands and my forte was more writing guitar hooks than writing songs.

I still jam and gig. learning songs, working out solos, arrangements, all keep me going.
 

Guildedagain

Enlightened Member
Joined
Jun 8, 2016
Messages
9,106
Reaction score
7,266
Location
The Evergreen State
"I play therefore I am".

I like to wake up in the morning, reach over, play the first thing that comes into my head, and try to get all of the scale intervals right. It's math really, and perception of tone, and familiarity, the more you play, the better your ear gets.

"my forte was more writing guitar hooks than writing songs"

I'm very riffy. Whenever I pickup a guitar, I come up with a riff, but I've never been very song oriented at all.

I can improv over anything for hours.

I like to pickup a bass while watching a movie and writing a score in real time, I never get tired of it. Tons of tones you would not think of otherwise.

I guess I like playing best as a response to something I'm hearing, when I'm inspired.

It's your brain, processing, data input and in the moment sonic response, programmed sequences that fit certain patterns, sometimes breaking out into the unknown.
 
Last edited:

Mark WW

Member
Joined
Aug 5, 2006
Messages
660
Reaction score
99
Location
Floriduh
Been playing on and off for 60 years (WOW) and started collecting just for fun about 12 or 13 years ago. I am now down to less than 2 handfull's of guitars and would like to lose a couple more (one handfull). Why do I play? I like music. Not sure that what I do can always be called music but it ius what it is. Oh GGJaguar already said "it is"...
 

jp

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 21, 2006
Messages
4,883
Reaction score
1,800
Location
Pacific Northwest US
Guild Total
4
I've played guitar since I was about 8 or 9. For me, music became the most fulfilling thing in my life, and I was obsessed for many years through college and into my mid-20s. It provided all the freedom, creativity, and escape from everything in life I didn't like, and to some extent it still is. Outside of my family, I would say it consumes the majority of my thoughts.

When I discovered Guilds, the collector bug bit me, and I started to pursue specific models, though not to the extent that many here have. Nor do I even own enough guitars to be called a collector. According to consumer research, I'm a pretty average guitar owner with only one bass, four amps, six guitars, one baritone uke, and a smattering of pedals and electronic foo.
 

lungimsam

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 1, 2011
Messages
2,632
Reaction score
1,696
Guild Total
2
My Lord and Savior Jesus Christ gifted me with the ability to play bass and guitar so I serve Him by playing on the worship team at church.
 

dreadnut

Gone But Not Forgotten
Gone But Not Forgotten
Joined
Jun 15, 2005
Messages
16,082
Reaction score
6,443
Location
Grand Rapids, MI
Guild Total
2
50+ years for me. I picked up the guitar because I wanted to lead songs around the campfire. I've done plenty of that, been in a few bands, played in a lot of different venues. Now my primary focus is singing with the Alzheimer's folks, and leading the church band.

I still play a few Classic Rock & Roll gigs, and some Bluegrass gigs.
 

Guildedagain

Enlightened Member
Joined
Jun 8, 2016
Messages
9,106
Reaction score
7,266
Location
The Evergreen State
still thinking about selling both to fund getting a good one of those hybrid guitars just to make it easier to play acoustic as my hands get weaker.

My recent grab F30CE sig guitar, 24 frets, low action, quite possibly has better action than any electric I own, not just low but easy, Gibson scale makes it a real rocker with a little darker tone.

Access to the upper registers rivals most electrics somehow.
 
Top