What makes a good banjo?

dreadnut

Gone But Not Forgotten
Gone But Not Forgotten
Joined
Jun 15, 2005
Messages
16,082
Reaction score
6,442
Location
Grand Rapids, MI
Guild Total
2
Ugh @dreadnut thats twice you’ve recommended mandolin over banjo - maybe I should just try both? 😃👍

Yeah, you can realistically get a sufficient banjo to try for $150, if it doesn't work out, you're not out many shekels.

For me, the banjo is so different from the guitar that I need to re-train my mind in order to play it. It's fun on a few songs, mostly bluegrass, but it takes me away from learning new stuff on the guitar.

I pretty much only know 3 chords on bpth the mandolin and the banjo: G,C, and D. On the mando I can capo up two and be in A. And on the mando, if I'm not playing a bluegrass chop, I just tinkle along with scales, which seem to me are laid out very logically on the mandolin. Scales in G, scales in D, scales in A, and capoed varieties of each.
 

F312

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 12, 2008
Messages
2,760
Reaction score
958
Yeah, you can realistically get a sufficient banjo to try for $150, if it doesn't work out, you're not out many shekels.

For me, the banjo is so different from the guitar that I need to re-train my mind in order to play it. It's fun on a few songs, mostly bluegrass, but it takes me away from learning new stuff on the guitar.

I pretty much only know 3 chords on bpth the mandolin and the banjo: G,C, and D. On the mando I can capo up two and be in A. And on the mando, if I'm not playing a bluegrass chop, I just tinkle along with scales, which seem to me are laid out very logically on the mandolin. Scales in G, scales in D, scales in A, and capoed varieties of each.

...and what sort of "G" would that be, per se. :unsure:

Ralph
 

SFIV1967

Venerated Member
Joined
Nov 20, 2010
Messages
18,497
Reaction score
9,023
Location
Bavaria / Germany
Guild Total
8
The closest thing to a Guild banjo: The Madeira by Guild banjos! There were 3 versions, the BA-5, the B-5 and the B-10.

1616196239379.png


1616196324195.png


The BA-5 was the first one in the '70s. It had a $220 list proce.
Later it was replaced by a B-5 and a higher end model, the B-10. According to the March 1, 1982 pricelist the list price for the B-5 was $179.50 and the B-10 was $269.50, so 50% more expensive. Not sure what the exact spec differences between the 3 were.

Ralf
 
Last edited:

Brucebubs

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2018
Messages
2,163
Reaction score
1,605
Location
Eden, Australia
Didn't you guys read the new warning?

I know we're all tired of the current situation, but no banjos means no banjos. That means don't post things that are even a little bit banjo - even in jest. If you see something that you think is banjo don't post a reply - report the post!
 

walrus

Reverential Member
Gold Supporting
Joined
Dec 23, 2006
Messages
24,025
Reaction score
8,113
Location
Massachusetts
Didn't you guys read the new warning?

I know we're all tired of the current situation, but no banjos means no banjos. That means don't post things that are even a little bit banjo - even in jest. If you see something that you think is banjo don't post a reply - report the post!

LMAO! I had been ignoring this thread, well, because it is about banjos. Not my cup of tea. But I just popped in and this has me still chuckling to myself! :ROFLMAO:

walrus
 

Cougar

Enlightened Member
Joined
Nov 28, 2015
Messages
5,412
Reaction score
3,140
Location
North Idaho
Guild Total
5
Didn't you guys read the new warning?

I know we're all tired of the current situation, but no banjos means no banjos. That means don't post things that are even a little bit banjo - even in jest. If you see something that you think is banjo don't post a reply - report the post!

Oh, I thought that only pertained to that sect of extremist fundamentalist banjoists. Yeah, I'd steer clear of them!
 

hansmoust

Enlightened Member
Joined
Jun 10, 2005
Messages
9,225
Reaction score
3,574
Location
Netherlands
Oh, I thought that only pertained to that sect of extremist fundamentalist banjoists. Yeah, I'd steer clear of them!

Yes that ......... and women banjo players!

BanjoGirl.jpeg


P.S. In Holland we do not obey 'political correctness', but we do wear a mask!

Sincerely,

Hans Moust
www.guitarsgalore.nl
 
Last edited:

Westerly Wood

Venerated Member
Joined
Mar 21, 2007
Messages
13,422
Reaction score
6,621
Guild Total
2
What makes a good banjo?

This is a rhetorical question, right?

:)

bluegrass, i really want to like that form of music, if they could just remove the fiddle...
 

wileypickett

Enlightened Member
Joined
Jun 18, 2009
Messages
5,008
Reaction score
4,573
Location
Cambridge, MA
IMO, banjos are the cat's meow!

If you're thinking of getting started, great!, but there are a few things to consider.

Imagine saying, "I want to take up the the guitar, what do people recommend?" Are you interested in the guitar because you love Segovia? Leo Kottke? Joe Pass? Doc Watson? Jimi Hendrix? How you answer that question will suggest what kind of guitar you might want to start with.

Same with banjo.

People associate the banjo with bluegrass, and rightly so -- Earl Scruggs was an innovator on par with any musician you'd care to name, and he invented and / or perfected virtually every technique employed by bluegrass banjo players of the past 60+ years.

But bluegrass banjo is not the only style.

I'm most fond of Appalachian style banjo, also called frailing or clawhammer.

There are classical banjo players.

The banjo isn't used in jazz much anymore, but the greatest surge in banjo popularity (prior to Scruggs) was when it was used as a rhythm instrument by just about every jazz combo in existence from the '20s to the early '50s. Their ubiquity is why you still see so many vintage tenor (4-string) banjos on the vintage market. Tens of thousands of the (damn) things were sold.

If you like bluegrass style banjo, you'll likely prefer the sound of a resonator-backed banjo, usually played with fingerpicks. These banjos are admred for their volume, projection, and their responsivness to an aggressive attack. (When people describe high-volume guitars as "banjo killers," these are the banjos they're trying to kill.)

If you like clawhammer style, you'll likley prefer an openback banjo, which have more "thump," or "cluck," and are played with the backs of the fingernails and thumb -- no fingerpicks.

If you're not sure, I recommend going to a decent music store that stocks both styles of banjos and taking a whack at them and seeing which you like the sound of. You could also go on YouTube and search for "bluegrass banjo," "clawhammer banjo," etc., and see if you prefer one style over another.

As with all things there are no rules -- you can do whatever you like with any instrument. Buy or borrow one and just fool around with it.

And while G is considered standard tuning for banjo, there are dozens of tunings, many of them associated with specific songs played in those tunings. (As with the guitar, I just make up my own banjo tunings.)

There are also many different kinds of tone-rings, the part the head is seated on. (And some banjos have no tone-ring.) People discuss tone-rings on banjo chat groups with the same kind of sweaty-browed fervor that people discuss rosewood, versus mahogany, versus maple, on guitar chat groups.
 
Last edited:

Cougar

Enlightened Member
Joined
Nov 28, 2015
Messages
5,412
Reaction score
3,140
Location
North Idaho
Guild Total
5
If you like clawhammer style, you'll likley prefer an openback banjo, which have more "thump," or "cluck," and are played with the backs of the fingernails and thumb -- no fingerpicks..... As with all things there are no rules -- you can do whatever you like with any instrument....

Thanks, Glenn. Yeah, I'm likely a clawhammer and do-whatever-you-like type, though I'll likely do some non-Scruggs type fingerpicking, too. I'm looking at an inexpensive Washburn B7 openback, thinking that'll be good enough to play around with? Looks like a geared 5th string at least....
 

walrus

Reverential Member
Gold Supporting
Joined
Dec 23, 2006
Messages
24,025
Reaction score
8,113
Location
Massachusetts
IMO, banjos are the cat's meow!

Well, that's close to my feeling, too. Except I would say the cat has just had his tail stepped on.

And +1 on Woody's fiddle feelings.

I know, I'm in the minority, I can take it. I just never cared for the whole bluegrass thing at all. I was impressed with David Rawlings for awhile after I happened to buy a '33 Epiphone Olympic - since sold - but it was short lived. Great player but not my kind of music.

walrus
 

Sal

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 5, 2011
Messages
1,450
Reaction score
1,164
Location
Minneapolis
Just remember, if you keep pickin that it could get bigger.

1616652157271.png
 
Top