Review of Guild F-2512e 12-string

Ardor13

Junior Member
Joined
Jul 29, 2019
Messages
41
Reaction score
5
Greetings,

This review is for a new Guild F-2512e 12-string. I have significant experience playing 12 string electric and acoustics, but with no prior experience of playing Guilds. I'll do my best to be objective. I won't be able to compare it with other Guilds, but only against my subjective experience. So thank you in advance for your grace in this regard.

First of all, I got a smoking deal on this guitar from Sweetwater. It was slightly damaged (headstock chip), so they gave it to me for $329 out the door. They advertised that a case was included, but it arrived without any case, and through some magic in their honor-system, they ended up shipping me a $150 Guild Humidicase at no cost. They earned my business. Amazing!

My purpose for getting the guitar was because I needed a second guitar to keep in DADGAD tuning. Most people will attest that it is not practical to retune 6 of the 12 strings back and forth between DADGAD and Standard. Perfect excuse for extra guitar!

The guitar is simple, yet beautiful, cosmetically flawless, and well-made. One thing I noticed was how light it felt, for the size. But it does not feel "cheap". It's always a joy to open the Guild case and pull this thing out. The natural blond color really stands out, when viewed in person. The action was a little high for my liking, so I had a luthier make some adjustments to the truss. He said the Nut is cut pretty low, for what it's worth. The Bridge is a pretty fat/tall piece of wood, but he cranked the truss to maximum, and the strings got pretty low. Most likely you would not need to sand the bridge unless you need a very-very low action. That said, I actually had him set the action back up a little higher, because the tone was less "full' when the action was very low-- it had become noticeably less bassy, and much more trebly, but not a full treble-- more of a cymbal-like sizzle that was not pleasing to my ears. This is relative to playing methods/styles, so ymmv. But as always, there's a tonal compromise with action and string tension to consider, and I've noticed in the past that this compromise can be exaggerated on 12 strings. So with the action back up, the tone was closer to how it sounded before, but easier to play up the neck than with the original action. Perhaps later I will try a heavier gauge string set, and set the action lower. I should add that when the luthier picked it up, the first thing he said was that it was very light for a Guild. He checked with a mirror and said the bracing was alot lighter than higher-end guilds. He said the Guilds he knows have "Very strong, I mean very strong..." bracing. That said, I have no doubt the bracing is sufficient for the lighter body wood of this guitar. He said the glue on the braces looked good. I remarked on the slightly raised top, under the bridge, which he confirmed is by-design, and not bowing from string tension. We both noticed the bridge was slightly tilted forward, but was firmly glued to the top, so this is probably no issue at all, and perhaps by design.

The tuners do their job... while they are not Grovers, I have not had any tuning difficulties. When holding the guitar, the tuners do not give the impression of being very heavy, as the headstock does not feel heavy in the hand, like some 12s. As for keeping it in tune, I had to make a few adjustments over the the next days, but once the strings get locked down, they pretty much stay where they are. Some days I don't have to tune it at all. I am doing mainly finger style, so I'm less likely to knock tuning out, as with heavy strumming. I have not gigged out with it, so I have not experienced whether the guitar resists moisture/temperature changes well. I trust that it will do just fine.

As for the d'addario coated 80/20 EXP light strings, which come installed... they seem fine with this guitar. In the past I have not been drawn to coated strings, but I have no basis to say what other strings would sound like on this guitar until I try them. I will inevitably check to see what non-coated strings will do-- perhaps uncoated bronze or mayyybe phosphor bronze.

As mentioned, I play this guitar in DADGAD, and it sounds amazing this way. The bass is FAT, and you can feel the sound-box resonating against your chest-- Something I am not used to from playing smaller body 12's. The guitar is warm, and gets some nice upper harmonics, but it's not "Tears go by" either. The sustain is good, but it does not sustain as much as some 12's I have played. The volume is rather loud while playing, and while there is good sustain, the volume of the sustain drops off a bit more quickly than I am used to after sounding a chord or single notes. When I tuned this baby up to standard, the bass was obviously less pronounced but still firm. The sound of this guitar is decent in Standard, but for me it really opens up in DADGAD. In general, what I've noticed about the tone of this guitar (in DADGAD), is that there are various discrete dynamics that come out: 1.) The general bass resonance which I mentioned, 2.) a sort of percussive striking sound when I pluck the strings... hard to describe, but I'd say it's a distinct bass/low-mids percussion (almost like an echo) that accompanies each strike of a note. Again, this affect is more pronounced in DADGAD than in standard, but still present. 3.) Some decent singing highs. I would not say the singing is gloriously rich, at least for my style of playing, but it does sing and sparkle when I do it right. Perhaps some touches of glory here and there. :) And I'm not going to say you can't make it sing more than me. :) I don't use a pick, so maybe that would add some sparks.

The pickup, is an unremarkable Piezo, with some quack. I tried plugging it into an LR Baggs Para Acoustic DI (with on-board EQ), and out through a Roland AC-60 acoustic amp. No matter how hard I tried, I never was able to get the EQ set to a satisfactory tone on this rig. Some people have said it sounds great, but I'm not convinced. I will personally avoid using it. Your mileage may vary, but I bought this guitar with the intention of using a microphone for live and recording, so I did not have my hopes up about the piezo. For the cost, I can't complain, especially with the deal I got. I mic'd it up with a 57 through the same amp, and it sounds pretty darn good like that. This is a personal preference, but if I could magically make the pickup disappear, I would probably go for it, just to see if the guitar's resonance would find benefit.

The inclusion of the bone nut and saddle is a nice and unexpected feature for a $500 street-value guitar.

Overall, a great guitar for the price I got, but also a good deal if you grab one with a 15% coupon code on GC or MF, etc. I'm not confident whether you could find a better 12'er in this price range. It is a bit of a rocker, and previous adjectives like "cannon" are warranted.
 
Last edited:

ezstrummer

Member
Joined
Jan 22, 2018
Messages
246
Reaction score
78
Location
US
Nice review. I bought mine new about a year ago. I feel it has a trebly sound to it. I bought new strings but have not had the time to try them yet. My over all opinion is its a great 12 string for the price.
 

ezstrummer

Member
Joined
Jan 22, 2018
Messages
246
Reaction score
78
Location
US
Nice review. I bought mine new about a year ago. I feel it has a trebly sound to it. I bought new strings but have not had the time to try them yet. My over all opinion is its a great 12 string for the price.

I just bought the new Deluxe of this same model and I couldn't be happier with the sound. It is exactly what I wanted in a 12 string. I recommend it highly..

1589198492361.png
 

HeyMikey

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 12, 2018
Messages
3,076
Reaction score
2,093
Location
MA
Guild Total
10
Excellent review Ardor13 ! Congtrats. I had one for a brief period but had to sell it soon because of shoulder pain from arthritis. The jumbos are just too big for me these days. No construction or playability issues, and overall it is a very good value for a new 12 string.

Mine only came with a gig bag, as I believe is the norm, so the free premium case was a big win.
 

mclkar54

Member
Joined
May 5, 2021
Messages
155
Reaction score
69
Guild Total
1
just recently purchased an f2512 e, completely blown away by a sub 1000.00 dollar guitar. Made a few personal adjustments, and added martin retro monel 10-47 sttings. Big difference from the daddarios that came on it.This is a tremendously versatile guitar.Couldnt be happier.
 

gjmalcyon

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 6, 2011
Messages
3,602
Reaction score
1,325
Location
Gloucester County, NJ
Guild Total
11
just recently purchased an f2512 e, completely blown away by a sub 1000.00 dollar guitar. Made a few personal adjustments, and added martin retro monel 10-47 sttings. Big difference from the daddarios that came on it.This is a tremendously versatile guitar.Couldnt be happier.

Glad you're liking your new 12-er. I see a first post: Welcome! Stick around - nice folks around here.

And we'll do what we can to help you "improve" your Guild total.
 

mclkar54

Member
Joined
May 5, 2021
Messages
155
Reaction score
69
Guild Total
1
I also found that tuning down a full step from standard opens this guitar up. My plans going forward ,are to upgrade tuner machines to a gold grover delux, or 505g grovers, However ,i believe the 505g,s will have too short of tuning post.I had removed one tuner, and using a digital caliper took all necessary measurements to get correct size tuners. Any suggestions?
 

mclkar54

Member
Joined
May 5, 2021
Messages
155
Reaction score
69
Guild Total
1
Glad you're liking your new 12-er. I see a first post: Welcome! Stick around - nice folks around here.

And we'll do what we can to help you "improve" your Guild total.
Thank you
 

Cougar

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 28, 2015
Messages
3,999
Reaction score
1,320
Location
North Idaho
Guild Total
3
just recently purchased an f2512 e, completely blown away by a sub 1000.00 dollar guitar.

And sometimes sub-$500! I mean, what a deal for a MIC Guild 12-string! Major congrats on a very smart acquisition! And welcome to the boards!
 

Longnose Gar

Member
Gold Supporting
Joined
Jan 3, 2020
Messages
109
Reaction score
86
Location
Boulder, CO
Guild Total
7
I've had a small journey with Guild 12-strings. The F2512e was the first "extra" guitar I bought - I'd just had a Martin D16 for years. I loved it and then the bridge came unglued after a year. Cordoba sent me a replacement. Then my local shop had a D4-12 on consignment. I loved the sound and sold my F2512e to a friend. After a while, I realized I didn't like the neck as much on the D4-12. And the D4-12 is a tank. I had also put a pricey LR Baggs Anthem pickup in it and couldn't reproduce the acoustic sound through my PA. So I traded back with my friend for the F21512e (good deal for him, he loves the neck and doesn't plug in). Then the F2512e bridge came unglued, again ( and I keep it in a humidified rom). Cordoba sent me another one promptly. This third F2512e had the best neck of all. I like satin necks and the action was superb out of the box. But the grass still seemed greener, so I picked up a cheap used F1512e. Had it set up and everything and I just didn't like the fit and finish as much as the simpler, cheaper F2512e. I wouldn't say the tone was better, just different. So I sold the F1512e.

I agree the piezo does not do it justice, so I put in a K&K, run it through a Boss AD-2 and into the mixer and it sounds great through the PA.
 

Cougar

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 28, 2015
Messages
3,999
Reaction score
1,320
Location
North Idaho
Guild Total
3
....so I picked up a cheap used F1512e. Had it set up and everything and I just didn't like the fit and finish as much as the simpler, cheaper F2512e.....
Ha! Great story, Gar! Ya go with what ya like!
 

mclkar54

Member
Joined
May 5, 2021
Messages
155
Reaction score
69
Guild Total
1
Thank you
have now had this 2512 fir a couple months. Switched out tuner to gold grovers. And tried a set of D R Rare 12 string set. Big differance from my normal martin retro monels. On this guitar, the dr,s will be a permanent string change. i love this 12 string , for the price you get a lot more guitar than pricier 12 strings, .. To note' i also own an f 412, just recently acquired. Without a doubt ,the absolute best guitar i have ever played, owned ,or held.47 years of playing guitars.
 
Joined
Jun 8, 2021
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Location
Oxnard, CA
Guild Total
1
have now had this 2512 fir a couple months. Switched out tuner to gold grovers. And tried a set of D R Rare 12 string set. Big differance from my normal martin retro monels. On this guitar, the dr,s will be a permanent string change. i love this 12 string , for the price you get a lot more guitar than pricier 12 strings, .. To note' i also own an f 412, just recently acquired. Without a doubt ,the absolute best guitar i have ever played, owned ,or held.47 years of playing guitars.
Do you have specs on the Grovers? My F-2512e is en route from CME. Want to get upgraded tuners ordered for setup/string change. My Starfire is looking forward to getting a 12-string brothrr! Cheers!
 

wileypickett

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 18, 2009
Messages
3,884
Reaction score
2,370
Location
Cambridge, MA
I'm also fond of this model -- and I've no shortage of Guild jumbo 12-strings on hand to compare it to.

I use D'Addario Mediums and play strictly in open tunings, with the E string tuned down to A or B.

Not all guitars take to silk-and-steel strings, but this one does. You might try 'em if you like experimenting with different strings.

Welcome!
 

mclkar54

Member
Joined
May 5, 2021
Messages
155
Reaction score
69
Guild Total
1
Do you have specs on the Grovers? My F-2512e is en route from CME. Want to get upgraded tuners ordered for setup/string change. My Starfire is looking forward to getting a 12-string brothrr! Cheers!
512g tuners
 
Joined
Jun 8, 2021
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Location
Oxnard, CA
Guild Total
1
Just installed upgraded tuners on my new F-2512e. Gotoh SG381 locking, Schaller type with keystone buttons. Length was slightly short, so tightening the posts was a bit tricky and took extra time/care. They look great and 2 weeks in, strings have stretched and no slippage.

Amazon link:

Gotoh Locking Tuners - Schaller Type - SG381 Chrome (3 per side). https://www.amazon.com/dp/B074KNQHL...t_i_BVPC2016WMWPX88Q5FFP?_encoding=UTF8&psc=1
 

Attachments

  • FB9A3F51-1ECE-43BF-80FB-F0848F516E3F.jpeg
    FB9A3F51-1ECE-43BF-80FB-F0848F516E3F.jpeg
    928.4 KB · Views: 49

mclkar54

Member
Joined
May 5, 2021
Messages
155
Reaction score
69
Guild Total
1
Do you have specs on the Grovers? My F-2512e is en route from CME. Want to get upgraded tuners ordered for setup/string change. My Starfire is looking forward to getting a 12-string brothrr! Cheers!
Grover 102 vg tuners. correct post length.
 
Top