Donal said:
I'd be interested in knowing how your trade goes. I had tried to consign instruments at Elderly a few times in the past
and could never bring myself to agree with the way they wanted things done. They have a good rep, but they can be slick.
Not as well as I hoped. I described the guitars pretty accurately, and they agreed on the less expensive one. On the Gibson Chet Atkins CE, I described it as:
"As far as I know, all original parts. Back has finish wear probably from a belt buckle, top has a fair amount of wear probably form aggressive picking, maybe with a flatpick or (metal?) fingerpicks. Some tarnish on the metal parts. Case is original except for the handle. I would call the case in fair shape. Plays well and sounds well amplified."
Their reply:
"Thanks for contacting us. We would sell this, as described, in the $1200-1400 range. To buy or in trade it is worth $800-1000. You might consider consignment, our fee is only 15%. I'd be happy to answer any other questions."
Their final offer was $500, saying it needed $83 worth of work (not disputing that), and that they would probably sell it for $800. I would have agreed with the $800 minus the work they say it needs, even if they had gone to $700 or $650 considering the cosmetic condition of the instrument. I'll be very interested in seeing what they finally list it for. If it is, as they say, to be listed for $800 or so, it's a bargain for someone who wants a playable one rather than a collectible.
Brad