Mustang8t4
Junior Member
- Joined
- Jul 1, 2021
- Messages
- 12
- Reaction score
- 4
- Guild Total
- 2
Heard they discontinued the D 20e. I have one and love it. Hope its not true
I am a Luddite about many aspects of life, and mostly prefer the old ways, and the old things. With respect to acoustic guitars I feel there is a certain "purity" to those without pick-ups.To be honest, unless there's something specialized to be offered (like a Fishman Aura, or a Taylor ES), then I'd wholly prefer a guitar without electronics. In fact when I picked up my parlor guitar through Godin, I had to expressly ask for no electronics. It's easy to have that done after you have the guitar, and you know what you want.
A Godin without electronics? Isn't that all they do?To be honest, unless there's something specialized to be offered (like a Fishman Aura, or a Taylor ES), then I'd wholly prefer a guitar without electronics. In fact when I picked up my parlor guitar through Godin, I had to expressly ask for no electronics. It's easy to have that done after you have the guitar, and you know what you want.
I feel pretty much the same way. More to the point, for me, is that old electronics (for acoustics) are bad electronics, in my opinion. I don't want 'em in my guitars because I don't love the sound. Forget about the barn doors or holes in the body, though that certainly is an issue to me.I am a Luddite about many aspects of life, and mostly prefer the old ways, and the old things. With respect to acoustic guitars I feel there is a certain "purity" to those without pick-ups.
. . .
It’s really the barn doors or big tone/volume knobs that turn me off. Old electronics can be removed/replaced but barn doors are usually a non-starter for me.I feel pretty much the same way. More to the point, for me, is that old electronics (for acoustics) are bad electronics, in my opinion. I don't want 'em in my guitars because I don't love the sound. Forget about the barn doors or holes in the body, though that certainly is an issue to me.
I wonder if they'd build a guitar without epoxy in the neck for me, I doubt it, but that's what's holding me back from another cedar maple comboTo be honest, unless there's something specialized to be offered (like a Fishman Aura, or a Taylor ES), then I'd wholly prefer a guitar without electronics. In fact when I picked up my parlor guitar through Godin, I had to expressly ask for no electronics. It's easy to have that done after you have the guitar, and you know what you want.
I am a Luddite about many aspects of life, and mostly prefer the old ways, and the old things. With respect to acoustic guitars I feel there is a certain "purity" to those without pick-ups.
My 1974 Martin D-28 was built without them, and my very early Guild GAD jf-30 lacks any trace of them as well.
However, my 2001 Gibson j-45 has a female jack in the bottom of the lower bout, although all other traces of electronics are missing, and while its presence has no effect on the guitar's performance, I wish it wasn't there, as it somehow spoils the "feel" of the instrument for me.
My other acoustic, a Washburn parlour was electrified for me by a friend, so I could use it in our grand-daughter's guitar lessons and performances where I accompany her.
I made certain that with the exception of the female input jack, the rest of the electronics are easily removable, and lately I have taken them out, just because. Again, the guitar seems "purer" without them, and I do have an electric guitar that I can use for lessons and school concerts.
I realize that for many others, the presence of electronics in acoustic guitars is important for any number of reasons, but for my musical needs, and my emotional well being, I like my instruments without them.
RBSinTo
I wonder if they'd build a guitar without epoxy in the neck for me, I doubt it, but that's what's holding me back from another cedar maple combo
I feel pretty much the same way. More to the point, for me, is that old electronics (for acoustics) are bad electronics, in my opinion. I don't want 'em in my guitars because I don't love the sound. Forget about the barn doors or holes in the body, though that certainly is an issue to me.
Having said that, I was really awed at our final Let's Meet Guild event when I was first exposed to the D-TAR multi-source system that Guild started using in New Hartford. That was the first system that rivaled or exceeded the sound of a good microphone.