If you've got a floating ground then when you touch the strings you become the ground. If you also happen to be touching something with a proper earth ground then you become the path to earth and that's when things get frightening. That's what happened to my daughter in the above post.
A combination of multiple grounding problems can make everything more difficult to figure out. For example if your LED lights are on the same circuit as your guitar amp and there's a floating ground, then you could be hearing buzz from the lights that isn't EMF if the path to ground decides to have something to do with your amp.
Ground loops can be small (within a guitar) or huge (entire rooms or more) and can be a royal PITA to resolve. If your X500 is the only properly wired guitar then that could explain why it's not picking up EMF, while the others do. You may have EMF *and* ground problems.
AcornHouse is correct in that a bad solder joint could be causing your issue as could 100 other things which is why these problems can be maddening, especially with a bunch of know-it-alls trying to diagnose it over a forum.