Page 2 of 8 FirstFirst 1234 ... LastLast
Results 11 to 20 of 77

Thread: F50R New Hartford slightly superior to Westerly JF55 tonewise?

  1. #11
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Feb 2006
    Location
    Planet Earth
    Posts
    4,330
    I don't get the issue with Antney's post. It reads to me that he dais that sometimes a mass produced low cost guitar can sometimes sound better than an expensive boutique type guitar.

  2. #12
    Quote Originally Posted by FNG View Post
    I don't get the issue with Antney's post. It reads to me that he dais that sometimes a mass produced low cost guitar can sometimes sound better than an expensive boutique type guitar.
    Me neither, but he might have edited the offensive bit.
    2011 Guild F50R Sunburst
    2002 Guild JF30-12 Sunburst
    2018 Gibson Ltd. Ed. Songwriter Deluxe 12-string
    2015 Martin GPC12PA4 12-string
    
2012 Epiphone Lennon EJ-160E VS

    
1972 Epiphone FT-160 12-string
    2012 Epiphone Dot CH

    2010 Epiphone Les Paul Standard trans amber 

    2013 Yamaha Motif XS7

  3. #13
    Senior Member adorshki's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2009
    Location
    Sillycon Valley CA
    Posts
    24,623
    Quote Originally Posted by FNG View Post
    I don't get the issue with Antney's post. It reads to me that he said that sometimes a mass produced low cost guitar can sometimes sound better than an expensive boutique type guitar.
    That's exactly how I read it too.
    Hoping Chaz won't take this wrong but sometimes he does misinterpret posts.
    And in fairness, sometimes they're not worded all that well, I should know. (insert sheepish grin emoji here)
    Quote Originally Posted by Cougar View Post
    Me neither, but he might have edited the offensive bit.
    Nope, edits show up with a time stamp, no edit.
    Al
    "Time May Change the Technique of Music But Never Its Mission " - Rachmaninoff
    My 1st Guild: '96 Westerly D25NT "Hally" (10-31-96 stamped on heelblock)
    #2: '01 Westerly F65ce "Blondie"
    #3: '03 Corona D40e Richie Havens "Richie"
    All bought new!

  4. #14
    Hoping Chaz won't take this wrong but sometimes he does misinterpret posts.


    Ha! About as often as Al is corrected???
    NH 2011 D-40 Standard
    NH 2014 Orpheum 000-12 Fret SH Hog
    NH 2010 F-412
    NH 2010 F-512
    NH 2012 F-30R Standard

    Westerly Songbird
    Westerly JF-30-12
    Westerly 1976 F-212
    Westerly 1971 D-25 CH
    Westerly 1982 D-70
    Westerly F4CE
    Westerly 1996 D-26...D for damaged by dummies

    Westerly Series OM-140 SB

    Ibanez V-302

    Madeira A-2...(don't laugh!)

  5. #15
    Senior Member adorshki's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2009
    Location
    Sillycon Valley CA
    Posts
    24,623
    Quote Originally Posted by beecee View Post
    Hoping Chaz won't take this wrong but sometimes he does misinterpret posts.


    Ha! About as often as Al is corrected???
    Not quite sure how to take that, but suspect there was a bit of elbow-in-the-ribs humor intended.
    In terms of raw count comparison, ie, misinterpretations vs corrections, I'm pretty sure I'm way ahead of him, but as percentage of total posts, even limiting 'em to my purely informational ones, I'd say my accuracy rate's pretty d--n good.
    Al
    "Time May Change the Technique of Music But Never Its Mission " - Rachmaninoff
    My 1st Guild: '96 Westerly D25NT "Hally" (10-31-96 stamped on heelblock)
    #2: '01 Westerly F65ce "Blondie"
    #3: '03 Corona D40e Richie Havens "Richie"
    All bought new!

  6. #16
    Quote Originally Posted by Antney View Post
    Hi Geoff

    I don’t understand questions like this one. Each guitar is tonally individual within itself. It begins with a completely unique set of organic materials that surrender themselves to the coincidence of human, mechanical, and chemical interaction to become the instruments we love or not. Even within that one instrument there are circumstances that enhance or prohibit optimum tone, either over the life of the instrument or even day to day. Comparisons therefore simply can’t hold any water.

    I can guarantee this, however: everyday in China a no-name brand guitar comes out of finishing with a tonal palette that surpasses that of a high end American made thud. It’s simply the coincidence of the interaction.
    I don't see anything offensive here - just a somewhat overstated attempt to say that no two guitars are the same.

    That said, I believe the point of the OP's question is quite valid. It is possible to draw generalizations about tone from various eras of a company's production, and frequently with guitars, a particular model will develop a signature tone - based on the best examples of that model over time. What's important to remember is that these are generalizations, and there will clearly be a spectrum of differences within any given model's (or era's) production.
    > Guilds: '73 F-30R / '74 F-40nt / '76 G-37bld / '92 D-6nt-hg / '94 JF-30nt / '97 Starfire III / '14 Savoy A-150b
    > Gibsons: '22 "A" Mandolin / '66 ES-125T / '66 Epi Cortez (B-25) / '90 Tennessean / '00 J-100xt / '02 J-45 RW / '02 SG / '07 CJ-165 / '09 ES-339 / '10 ES-330L / '11 ES-335 P90s / '12 ES-330 VOS / '12 LP Special / '12 J-185 / '13 LG-2 / '13 M.Kalamazoo / '14 J-15 / '15 J-50
    > Epis: '00 AIUSA Sheraton / '05 McCartney Texan / '09 Elitist Casino
    > Martins: '00 OOO-16 / '01 CS RW D

  7. #17
    Senior Member Westerly Wood's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2013
    Location
    Tucson, but wish it was Idaho or even Poland
    Posts
    5,988
    Quote Originally Posted by adorshki View Post
    Not quite sure how to take that, but suspect there was a bit of elbow-in-the-ribs humor intended.
    In terms of raw count comparison, ie, misinterpretations vs corrections, I'm pretty sure I'm way ahead of him, but as percentage of total posts, even limiting 'em to my purely informational ones, I'd say my accuracy rate's pretty d--n good.
    You and Chaz are two of my favorite LTGers so keep on keeping on in your respective talents and approaches to LTGness :)

  8. #18
    Senior Member adorshki's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2009
    Location
    Sillycon Valley CA
    Posts
    24,623
    Quote Originally Posted by Westerly Wood View Post
    You and Chaz are two of my favorite LTGers so keep on keeping on in your respective talents and approaches to LTGness :)
    So no showdown?



    Al
    "Time May Change the Technique of Music But Never Its Mission " - Rachmaninoff
    My 1st Guild: '96 Westerly D25NT "Hally" (10-31-96 stamped on heelblock)
    #2: '01 Westerly F65ce "Blondie"
    #3: '03 Corona D40e Richie Havens "Richie"
    All bought new!

  9. #19
    Senior Member Westerly Wood's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2013
    Location
    Tucson, but wish it was Idaho or even Poland
    Posts
    5,988
    Quote Originally Posted by adorshki View Post
    So no showdown?



    I got a small bag of gluten free popcorn ready to go.

  10. #20
    Not quite sure how to take that, but suspect there was a bit of elbow-in-the-ribs humor intended.

    It was in jest......but in retrospect, poorly written.
    NH 2011 D-40 Standard
    NH 2014 Orpheum 000-12 Fret SH Hog
    NH 2010 F-412
    NH 2010 F-512
    NH 2012 F-30R Standard

    Westerly Songbird
    Westerly JF-30-12
    Westerly 1976 F-212
    Westerly 1971 D-25 CH
    Westerly 1982 D-70
    Westerly F4CE
    Westerly 1996 D-26...D for damaged by dummies

    Westerly Series OM-140 SB

    Ibanez V-302

    Madeira A-2...(don't laugh!)

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •