Newark Street Pickup Balance

GSFV

Member
Joined
Jan 3, 2018
Messages
196
Reaction score
57
So I finally got around to switching those pickup locations. It was a new experience for me and a ton of fun! Thankfully I got it right on my first try. So that was good.

Not sure if it did what I wanted it to do. But it definitely sounds different. The neck and middle positions sound somehow more bassy. But in a different way. Almost more like a jazzy style.
The bridge also seems to have more treble. This, oddly, is what I was trying to get away from.

I think that a major part of that is the pickup casings/enclosure. The black pickup rings are made and styled differently. The bridge is much taller, so when I put it in the neck position I had to lower the pickup until it couldn't be lowered anymore to get the strings to ring. The neck pickup (now moved to the bridge position) was so low I had to raise it as tall as I could because of a substantial difference in volume.

Once I got the pickup heights where it sounds more balanced, I started to play around. I'm going to leave it like this for a little while simply to give my ears time to adjust. But I think I dislike the clean sounds more, but the dirty sounds are nice. Almost sounds like a typical classic rock type sound. It's nice, but not sure if that's what I'm going for. Regardless, a fun learning experience.

SO! in short: successful because the pickups work (moral victory for me). But I'm not sure that I'll keep them there. I do, however, have a few found appreciation for the beauty of my SFV. I've never had the pick guard off for this long. And the continual white finish really is spectacular. Thanks for the help and advice on how to do this. I probably wouldn't have had the courage to dive in on my own. Definitely a good learning experience! And I think I have a new appreciation for the way that Guild originally designed the pickups.


P.S. I just saw GAD's post about a Les Paul that was struggling, and a change in Pots was the fix! If I switch the pickups back, I'll probably get different pots. I have had issues with some buzz and fuzz while using the volumes. I may just get different pots just to try. It's certainly a cheap fix.
 
Last edited:

The Guilds of Grot

Enlightened Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2006
Messages
9,547
Reaction score
4,716
Location
New Jersey Shore
Guild Total
117
I think that a major part of that is the pickup casings/enclosure. The black pickup rings are made and styled differently. The bridge is much taller, so when I put it in the neck position I had to lower the pickup until it couldn't be lowered anymore to get the strings to ring. The neck pickup (now moved to the bridge position) was so low I had to raise it as tall as I could because of a substantial difference in volume.

You probably should have left the pick-up rings were they were and just swap the "body" of the pick-up.
 

GAD

Reverential Morlock
Über-Morlock
Joined
Feb 11, 2009
Messages
22,588
Reaction score
17,807
Location
NJ (The nice part)
Guild Total
112
So I finally got around to switching those pickup locations. It was a new experience for me and a ton of fun! Thankfully I got it right on my first try. So that was good.

Not sure if it did what I wanted it to do. But it definitely sounds different. The neck and middle positions sound somehow more bassy. But in a different way. Almost more like a jazzy style.
The bridge also seems to have more treble. This, oddly, is what I was trying to get away from.

I think that a major part of that is the pickup casings/enclosure. The black pickup rings are made and styled differently. The bridge is much taller, so when I put it in the neck position I had to lower the pickup until it couldn't be lowered anymore to get the strings to ring. The neck pickup (now moved to the bridge position) was so low I had to raise it as tall as I could because of a substantial difference in volume.

Once I got the pickup heights where it sounds more balanced, I started to play around. I'm going to leave it like this for a little while simply to give my ears time to adjust. But I think I dislike the clean sounds more, but the dirty sounds are nice. Almost sounds like a typical classic rock type sound. It's nice, but not sure if that's what I'm going for. Regardless, a fun learning experience.

SO! in short: successful because the pickups work (moral victory for me). But I'm not sure that I'll keep them there. I do, however, have a few found appreciation for the beauty of my SFV. I've never had the pick guard off for this long. And the continual white finish really is spectacular. Thanks for the help and advice on how to do this. I probably wouldn't have had the courage to dive in on my own. Definitely a good learning experience! And I think I have a new appreciation for the way that Guild originally designed the pickups.


P.S. I just saw GAD's post about a Les Paul that was struggling, and a change in Pots was the fix! If I switch the pickups back, I'll probably get different pots. I have had issues with some buzz and fuzz while using the volumes. I may just get different pots just to try. It's certainly a cheap fix.

Yes, the pickup rings are designed to position the pickup properly in it's position (bridge/neck), so they should not have moved.

As for pots, they can make a huge difference, but be advised of a couple of things:

1) Changing pots on a semi-hollow or hollow-body guitar is a HUGE pain in the <redacted by puritan forum software>. Read up on it before you attempt it.

2) The pots in a Newark Street Guild are likely metric and so the high-end pots of the type I would recommend for a Les Paul won't fit without drilling or reaming, which is something I'd not recommend unless you've got lots of experience working on finished wood.

Just think for a minute about what it took for me to get this picture. And then think about what I had to go through to get all of that back where it belonged.
Guild-1998-Starfire4-PotsHarness.jpg
 

Quantum Strummer

Senior Member
Joined
May 26, 2015
Messages
2,382
Reaction score
118
Location
Michigan
A couple things:

I don't find the 5K LB-1 (or the ~5K anti-hums in my Bluesbird) to be any brighter than the "standard" version. The treble has a more acoustic-y nature, a lot like an old Filter'Tron (and different to the TV Jones versions), but there isn't more of it. When I got my '71 S-100 I was surprised to find its HB-1s brighter than the reissue T-bird or vintage Bluesbird pickups. Could be due to these particular HB-1s being low-wind (7.1 & 6.9K) or maybe this S-100's pots are higher in impedance than normal. The smaller Guild HBs are skinnier in the mids, though, than the bigger ones.

If you go the replacement pots route, see if you can find a seller who'll measure 'em and sell you a set per your desired values. A guy I know bought a ton of Alpha pots years ago for his Burny LP copies (he's the reason I got into 'em) and in 2017 sold me eight of 'em each measuring 525K+. Those pots plus old Astron .022 caps are killer together.

-Dave-
 
Last edited:

GSFV

Member
Joined
Jan 3, 2018
Messages
196
Reaction score
57
Hmm....rookie mistake. Seems obvious that I should have left the pickup rings where they belong. Hindsight I guess.
I still don't love the change. I've been thinking about changing it back, but it sounds like switching the rings to be where they belong may help make a difference. At least then the pickups will be sitting where they ought to be. Which I know makes a huge difference.

I'm definitely not planning on doing the pots myself. I know Semi Hollowbodies can be a "pain in the <redacted by puritan forum software>" :highly_amused: to work on from other discussions I've seen and read. I definitely DO NOT have enough experience working on finished wood to try and drill or do anything. So that part is out of the question. If switching the rings don't work, I'll probably end up putting it all back the way that it is meant to be. I still love the guitar and would prefer to not make any changes that can't be quickly undone again.

The help here has been tremendous. Thanks everyone! And GAD, I can't imagine doing that. But I do love the picture. Your work is appreciated!

How do I move the pickup rings? Take the pickups out like last time, and then ...? Is there a solder connection that needs un-soldering? or a screw that holds it there? Would it be possible or worth it to try and lave the pickups connected and just move the rings?
 

Quantum Strummer

Senior Member
Joined
May 26, 2015
Messages
2,382
Reaction score
118
Location
Michigan
The pickups are mounted to the rings, so when you unscrew the four corner screws and lift up the ring the pickup will come with it. Then unscrew the pickup height adjusters to release the p'up from the ring. Make sure the springs on the height adjuster screws don't go flying across the room and down the basement stairs in the process. :)

-Dave-
 

GAD

Reverential Morlock
Über-Morlock
Joined
Feb 11, 2009
Messages
22,588
Reaction score
17,807
Location
NJ (The nice part)
Guild Total
112
The pickups are mounted to the rings, so when you unscrew the four corner screws and lift up the ring the pickup will come with it. Then unscrew the pickup height adjusters to release the p'up from the ring. Make sure the springs on the height adjuster screws don't go flying across the room and down the basement stairs in the process. :)

-Dave-

Also, store up some profanity for when you go to thread the screws back in through the springs when you're done. :)
 

GSFV

Member
Joined
Jan 3, 2018
Messages
196
Reaction score
57
I had some time this weekend and was kicking myself for not realizing I needed to change the pickup ring. And since I was taking it apart (and not overly thrilled with the results) I went ahead and swapped them back to normal. Plugged it in, and was immediately amazed at how different it was. I didn’t notice a difference switching places originally, but putting them back to normal I did. *sigh* I didn’t love it.

So I switched them again. lol. This time changing pickup rings. I was concerned and had plenty of profanity in storage, but didn’t get a chance to use it.

Here’s what is strange though, I still notice a considerable difference in volume. Where the neck position (which is a NS LB1 Bridge pickup) is still louder. I had to lower it by a lot, which is what I had to do when the neck pickup was in the neck spot. This has left me thoroughly confused.

I’m finding myself picking up my strat more and more lately. Which isn’t necessarily a bad thing. But I just can’t seem to get my Guild to sound like what I hear in my head. I am either completely lost in the band mix or have a neck pickup that’s muddy and dark even though it’s a bridge pickup.

I just can’t find that sweet spot where both pickups are usable. Bridge has nice bite/cut but isn’t harsh, and neck that is sweet/smooth without lacking definition and clarity.

Any advice? I’m thoroughly confused and getting frustrated. In fact, I’m almost ready to dip into that profanity that’s stored up.


P.S. each pickup is conveniently labeled as neck and bridge so it’s easy to put back to original. I’m also getting better at soldering, and getting more confident. I’m also learning. So. Huge thanks to you all for that! I don’t think I’d have the confidence to do all this without your help.

Thanks again!
 

GAD

Reverential Morlock
Über-Morlock
Joined
Feb 11, 2009
Messages
22,588
Reaction score
17,807
Location
NJ (The nice part)
Guild Total
112
Did you readjust the pickup heights after moving them? If you swap the pickups then the "hotter" pickup will be in the bridge and the bridge is usually where the hotter pickup goes. That means that if you had them adjusted the same way as before, then the bridge will be too hot and the neck will be too weak (why isn't the
opposite of hot, cold?).

I'm currently kind of questioning my own sanity because I just got a 2016 Starfire III with the mismatched pickups and they're not driving me crazy. They absolutely did on my T-Bird, so I need to see what's up with that. I'm wondering if there's some sort of dynamic at play on the hollow body that makes this weird combination work in a way that doesn't in other guitars. I haven't tried it at volume yet, though.

One of the things that I also learned the hard way when working on a Les Paul was that the pots have a huge impact on the tone of a guitar. This was a high-end Custom Shop model and I could not get the neck pickup to sound right at all. I dropped in two different boutique pickups and it was just completely uninspiring no matter what I put in ther. I was ready to sell it off and decided to replace the pots and the guitar just came alive. As it turns out, the pots for the neck pickup were only 375k Ohms. I swapped them with 525k Ohm pots and the guitar just exploded with tone. It's now one of my absolute favorites.

Pots, like most electronic components, come with a tolerance. What we assume to be a 500k pot likely shipped with +/-20% tolerance and the low end of that tolerance means you could have a 400k pot in there. Unfortunately there is no way to test a pot without pulling it. I also can't say for sure that this is your problem, but if it is, you can swap pickups all day long and you'll never be happy. At least you get some soldering practice in, though. :laughing:
 

GSFV

Member
Joined
Jan 3, 2018
Messages
196
Reaction score
57
I didn’t measure the height, so I just put it to where it looked right. And looking at it now, it isn’t has much of a difference as I remembered. Originally the heights were substantially different. I needed to do that to get the volume to match. They’re much closer now (with the pickup position switched), which leads me to believe that there is a big difference in the pickups. It came with the neck much lower than the bridge, and I lowered it more. Now that they’re switched they look closer in height.

I’m concerned it is a pot problem. The pots weren’t great to begin with. I needed to clean them right out of the box, but they functioned, which was all I knew to check for. Of course, that was also two years ago and I’ve grown as a player. So I’m possibly noticing problems now that I didn’t before but were possibly always present.

Someone mentioned earlier to be careful with changing pots as some may not fit quite right because it is a semi hollow? How would I know what size to buy?
 

GAD

Reverential Morlock
Über-Morlock
Joined
Feb 11, 2009
Messages
22,588
Reaction score
17,807
Location
NJ (The nice part)
Guild Total
112
I didn’t measure the height, so I just put it to where it looked right. And looking at it now, it isn’t has much of a difference as I remembered. Originally the heights were substantially different. I needed to do that to get the volume to match. They’re much closer now (with the pickup position switched), which leads me to believe that there is a big difference in the pickups. It came with the neck much lower than the bridge, and I lowered it more. Now that they’re switched they look closer in height.

I’m concerned it is a pot problem. The pots weren’t great to begin with. I needed to clean them right out of the box, but they functioned, which was all I knew to check for. Of course, that was also two years ago and I’ve grown as a player. So I’m possibly noticing problems now that I didn’t before but were possibly always present.

Someone mentioned earlier to be careful with changing pots as some may not fit quite right because it is a semi hollow? How would I know what size to buy?


It's not that it's a semi-hollow - it's that it's an import guitar. Import guitars come with metric sized holes where US guitars have imperial sized holes.

Replacing the pots is not a simple task, so beware of that. It's not impossible, but it's not exactly simple, either. Embrace the floss. :)
 

GSFV

Member
Joined
Jan 3, 2018
Messages
196
Reaction score
57
I’m also worried all of this means that a guild might not be right for me. But I’m fighting that thought. Surely buying nw gear isn’t the answer...? Is that G.A.S. I hear sneaking up on me? NO!!! Go away GAS!
 

GSFV

Member
Joined
Jan 3, 2018
Messages
196
Reaction score
57
So it’d be as simple as buying metric sized pots?
 

SFIV1967

Venerated Member
Joined
Nov 20, 2010
Messages
18,442
Reaction score
8,956
Location
Bavaria / Germany
Guild Total
8
So it’d be as simple as buying metric sized pots?
In general yes, but don't underestimate the work involved! Here's a great picture of our member Jahn who changed the electronics. Top Fin Airline Tubing (as used in aquariums) is a good helper as is dental floss.

IMG_1280.jpg
512P63B87AL.jpg



In a hollow body guitar you can go through the pickup cavity, in a semi-hollow body only through one f-hole!

Ralf
 
Last edited:

GSFV

Member
Joined
Jan 3, 2018
Messages
196
Reaction score
57
That is an absolutely gorgeous finish, Ralf. Wow!! Is that a Starfire VI?

I've heard of the dental floss trick, airline tubing is new. I've never delved into any of it before. So i'm trying to decide if I want to get my hands dirty, or take it to my local guy. I really trust him, but have been enjoying the work thus far. Decisions decisions.

So would it be possible to just take off/out the one pot? Or, because of the limitations of wire length, would I have to take all of them out, change the one pot, put them all back in? And if so, would it be worth it to just change everything out?

Would you recommend buying a prewired harness from guild? I believe they sell the entire thing already wired up for $60. Does that seems high? I know quality pots can be like 5-6 bucks. So...5 of those, plus a switch, and labor. Maybe not so bad?
 

SFIV1967

Venerated Member
Joined
Nov 20, 2010
Messages
18,442
Reaction score
8,956
Location
Bavaria / Germany
Guild Total
8
Yes, that is a Starfire VI, it is our member Jahn's guitar. Airline tubing works good as it keeps all better in position. I doubt you would be able to just change 1 pot. It depends which one it is and how the harness is currently soldered. Usually there is not a lot of wire inside so I would guess all 4 need to come out (at least from the mounting holes) until you have the pot which you want to change out the F-hole. You probably don't need to take all 4 out the F-hole. I don't think it makes sense to buy a complete harness from Guild as the pots would be the same (lower quality) as you have now. And it is not even 100% clear the pot is the culprit.
Ralf
 

GSFV

Member
Joined
Jan 3, 2018
Messages
196
Reaction score
57
Okay. That makes sense. So I'd probably need to release or at least loosen all of the pots, but would only need to pull the one that (potentially) needs replacing through the f-hole. Work on that, and then put it all back. I guess if it makes a world of difference I can go back and change out the other pots later. Where is a good place to get pots? Just Stew-Mac and CTS pots?
 
Top