Nitrocellulose Lacquer

adorshki

Reverential Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2009
Messages
34,176
Reaction score
6,790
Location
Sillycon Valley CA
Exactly. I'm still waiting for somebody to explain what it is and if Oxnard has the capabilities.
Yer havin' us on, aren'tcha? :glee:
But just in case, see post #10 and be aware that Oxnard has already produced guitars with a high gloss NCL finish, just like you got on your '79 D40.
Or maybe a little better due to improvements in the stuff over the years..
I guess it's about time to veer into the old "nitro vs poly" debate.
Nitro's better. Period.
:glee:
 
Last edited:

West R Lee

Venerated Member
Joined
Nov 19, 2005
Messages
17,741
Reaction score
2,663
Location
East Texas
Al, if it's a veer you're wanting, your last post caused me to become keenly aware of my vast ignorance. You mentioned "varnish". These past couple of years I've become pretty infatuated with Collings guitars and recently bought one (mine has a nitro finish). Varnish is one of the finishes they offer at Collings, but my gosh at the price tag. Collings is also pretty clear about the pros and cons of varnish in regards to acoustics. According to Collings (and I believe them), varnish is a much softer finish than nitro and is subject to nicks, dings, etc. Acoustically they say it's about as close to bare wood as you can get in a finish. They also say it changes color over time. But WHY is it so expensive? Anyone know?

West
 

adorshki

Reverential Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2009
Messages
34,176
Reaction score
6,790
Location
Sillycon Valley CA
According to Collings (and I believe them), varnish is a much softer finish than nitro and is subject to nicks, dings, etc. Acoustically they say it's about as close to bare wood as you can get in a finish. But WHY is it so expensive? Anyone know?

West
I'm gonna hazard a wild guess that it's because it's so time-consuming to finish an instrument that way, it's very slow drying, for starters.
I started a thread on finishes a while back:
http://www.letstalkguild.com/ltg/showthread.php?188931-Finishes/page4&highlight=catalyzed
Which contained this link:
http://www.aitchisoncellos.com/publ...-about-the-cello/understanding-cello-varnish/
Which contains this excerpt:
"However, classical makers resisted innovation in one crucial area: the use of pine resin in varnish. Traditionally, cooked pine resin was melted into a drying oil such as walnut or linseed oil, which formed the basis of most varnishes across Europe during the 16th century. If cooked slowly, the resulting varnish always remains soft and flexible: a beneficial quality for stringed instruments. By the time of Stradivarius, most other woodworkers and makers of other musical instrument families (e.g. keyboard and plucked strings) had adopted more durable finishes made from the tougher resins available at that time such as copal from the Far East, but the great classical makers continued to use their out-dated wood finishing methods and materials with the result that their varnishes have remained delicate and flexible in a way that has enhanced the sound and beauty of these instruments.

If a traditional linseed or walnut oil and pine resin varnish is cooked sufficiently slowly, it will never completely harden, but if you cook oil varnish over too high a temperature, it will harden very rapidly and will then change very little with the passage of time. A varnish which stays hard and glossy for over 100 years is far too hard, and is the antithesis of the best varnishes to have been produced. Varnish which remains soft is in a permanent state of chemical evolution as it reacts with the oxygen in the air and also with other elements which come into contact with it, such as moisture, sweat and skin, as well as changes in temperature. This process never ceases, causing significant changes to the structure of varnish over time, including the extraordinary fact that linseed oil varnish becomes alcohol soluble after about 200 years."


The takeaway from this is that after 200 years you should be careful when sipping single malt around your Collings.
 

West R Lee

Venerated Member
Joined
Nov 19, 2005
Messages
17,741
Reaction score
2,663
Location
East Texas
I'm gonna hazard a wild guess that it's because it's so time-consuming to finish an instrument that way, it's very slow drying, for starters.
I started a thread on finishes a while back:
http://www.letstalkguild.com/ltg/showthread.php?188931-Finishes/page4&highlight=catalyzed
Which contained this link:
http://www.aitchisoncellos.com/publ...-about-the-cello/understanding-cello-varnish/
Which contains this excerpt:
"However, classical makers resisted innovation in one crucial area: the use of pine resin in varnish. Traditionally, cooked pine resin was melted into a drying oil such as walnut or linseed oil, which formed the basis of most varnishes across Europe during the 16th century. If cooked slowly, the resulting varnish always remains soft and flexible: a beneficial quality for stringed instruments. By the time of Stradivarius, most other woodworkers and makers of other musical instrument families (e.g. keyboard and plucked strings) had adopted more durable finishes made from the tougher resins available at that time such as copal from the Far East, but the great classical makers continued to use their out-dated wood finishing methods and materials with the result that their varnishes have remained delicate and flexible in a way that has enhanced the sound and beauty of these instruments.

If a traditional linseed or walnut oil and pine resin varnish is cooked sufficiently slowly, it will never completely harden, but if you cook oil varnish over too high a temperature, it will harden very rapidly and will then change very little with the passage of time. A varnish which stays hard and glossy for over 100 years is far too hard, and is the antithesis of the best varnishes to have been produced. Varnish which remains soft is in a permanent state of chemical evolution as it reacts with the oxygen in the air and also with other elements which come into contact with it, such as moisture, sweat and skin, as well as changes in temperature. This process never ceases, causing significant changes to the structure of varnish over time, including the extraordinary fact that linseed oil varnish becomes alcohol soluble after about 200 years."


The takeaway from this is that after 200 years you should be careful when sipping single malt around your Collings.

Nah, my Collings has a nitro finish......just like my Guilds. But if it did, I'd make sure my great, great grandchildren were well aware.

West
 

adorshki

Reverential Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2009
Messages
34,176
Reaction score
6,790
Location
Sillycon Valley CA
Nah, my Collings has a nitro finish......just like my Guilds. But if it did, I'd make sure my great, great grandchildren were well aware.

West

Right, shoulda said "around a varnish-finished Collings".
Was pretty sure the single malt clause was valid.
Even if I do have a preference for McCormick's Platte Valley myself.
:friendly_wink:

201202261826454f4abfb5c99c2.jpg
 
Top