I'm a long time Hofner Club owner, so I'm a little biased to the unexpected side, considering this forum. It's been my experience that people either take to Hofners right away or don't.
Much of my decision is based on physical attributes, though. I'm short and when I play large basses, I look like a struggling little troll. Large body basses are also cumbersome for me when sitting, so I prefer smaller basses.
From a tonal side, Club Basses are also different beasts. The Hofner's fortes are the ability to get that McCartney-esque thunk we've all heard on Beatles recordings. Also, with flats, EQ-ing, and technique, it can sound very close to an upright. Admittedly, Hofner's electronics, can also be somewhat narrow in tonal variety, but for me, it's core sound outweighs that limitation. The necks are small and oddly shaped but super easy get around on, and chords and strumming are also easy to play. It's an extremely light bass, so it won't break your back.
I like the style of Starfires, since I played an Epihone Rivoli for years. I've played a few Guild Starfire basses with Hagstrom Bi-sonics, but not extensively, and they've always felt and sounded great. I've never played one with Hammon Darkstars. Of course, Starfires are also short scale, and the necks are comfortable. The strongest reason to choose a Starfire would probably be the tonal advantages. The Starfire is definitely more universal for different styles of music.
I agree with frono that mellowgerman will have some helpful insights to offer.